The group splits up to investigate and Velma who has taken an interest in Sam tells him to join her in the attic. While there Velma remarks on Sam's shoulders, as he is confused by her talking about his shoulders and she shyly shrugs it off before remarking on tries to tell Velma that the supernatural is real, but she denies it, firmly believing all ghosts and monsters are just people in costumes.
As Sam bid Velma farewell, Velma grabbed Sam, dipped him, then and kissed him on the lips. This surprised Sam, who looked after her with a smile. This prompted to Dean that he "should've known Velma was good to go", and that "it's always the quiet ones". After they got out and had Jay arrested, Sam commented that "Velma was right" about the whole thing being the work of a "shady real estate developer".