Teddy was originally a normal stuffed teddy bear but his owner Audrey wanted a teddy which was "big, real, and talked." She went to a wishing well and made a wish for him to be real and it was granted.
However, due to the curse on the Tiamat Coin which caused the wishes to come true, Teddy became addicted to pornography and alcohol, and was suicidal. He met the Winchesters who were shocked at the sight of a living stuffed animal but he surprised them with his views on the world in which he was appalled at the fact there was violence in the world and he called 'crap.' Teddy even questioned his existence and cried when he realized that he was alive for nothing more than 'tea parties.'
Teddy soon shot himself, but only managed to displace some of his stuffing, to his utter dismay.
- Michael Teigen, who portrayed Teddy, previously portrayed a teacher in season 1 episode Bloody Mary and Max Hilby in season 8 episode LARP and the Real Girl.