Supernatural Wiki

The Winchesters season 1 is currently streaming on The CW and HBO Max.

READ MORE

Supernatural Wiki
Register
Supernatural Wiki
mNo edit summary
Tag: sourceedit
Tag: rte-source
Line 3: Line 3:
 
This is NOT me hating on Sam at all, but seeing as they had absolutely no relationship with each other whatsoever, there's absolutely no reason for this page. -- [[User:ImperiexSeed|ImperiexSeed]], 3:47 AM, July 3rd 2015
 
This is NOT me hating on Sam at all, but seeing as they had absolutely no relationship with each other whatsoever, there's absolutely no reason for this page. -- [[User:ImperiexSeed|ImperiexSeed]], 3:47 AM, July 3rd 2015
   
How about deleted but moved to Sam's page in the relationship department. Despite only seeing her in the past for one episode, many of actions he does is from off his very limited time with his mother. As growning up, he didn't know a mother's love like Dean, but still was affected by her death. And every time he mentions her it's significant to his personality.[[User:Twilight Despair 5|[[User:Twilight Despair 5|]] ([[The God of Creation]])]] ([[User talk:Twilight Despair 5|talk]]) 16:46, July 3, 2015 (UTC)
+
How about deleted but moved to Sam's page in the relationship department. Despite only seeing her in the past for one episode, many of actions he does is from off his very limited time with his mother. As growning up, he didn't know a mother's love like Dean, but still was affected by her death. And every time he mentions her it's significant to his personality.[[User:Twilight Despair 5|[[User:Twilight Despair 5|]] ([[The God of Creation]])]] ([[User talk:Twilight Despair 5|talk]]) 16:46, July 3, 2015 (UTC)
   
 
Yes, please delete it. Mary had '''NO''' relationship or bond with Sam at all, so there's no need for it. -- [[User:ImperiexSeed|ImperiexSeed]], 3:41 AM, July 4th 2015
 
Yes, please delete it. Mary had '''NO''' relationship or bond with Sam at all, so there's no need for it. -- [[User:ImperiexSeed|ImperiexSeed]], 3:41 AM, July 4th 2015
   
 
This article should be deleted and merged with the relationships section of both characters, just like the other x and y character articles. Not because Sam only had six months with Mary before her death and Dean had years (both are still relationships), but because the information about all the different relationships the brothers had should just be included in each of the characters' respective articles. Essentially remove the listings of Sam and Mary, Dean and Mary, Dean and John, Sam and John, Sam and Dean, etc., and just consolidate it all into each characters' individual articles. By having multiple different articles for the relationships each character had with another character, readers are now forced to have to go to multiple different articles when they should really only need to read the one. Instead of having to read through [[Sam and Dean]], [[Sam and Castiel]], [[Sam and Crowley]], [[Sam and Bobby]], [[Sam and Jessica]], [[Sam and Ruby]], [[Sam and John]], [[Sam and Mary]], [[Sam and Ellen]], [[Sam and Jo]], [[Sam and Gordon]], [[Sam and Lucifer]], and [[Sam's Relationships]], or [[Sam and Dean|Dean and Sam]], [[Dean and Castiel]], [[Dean and Crowley]], [[Dean and Bobby]], [[Dean and John]], [[Dean and Jo]], [[Dean and Mary]], [[Dean and Benny]], [[Dean and Charlie]], [[Dean and Death]], [[Dean and Ellen]], [[Dean and Ruby]], [[Dean and Lisa]], and [[Dean's Relationships]], someone would only have to read the [http://supernatural.wikia.com/wiki/Sam_Winchester#Relationships relationships section of Sam's article], or the [http://supernatural.wikia.com/wiki/Dean_Winchester#Relationships relationship section of Dean's article]. That's 2 articles for 2 characters, instead of 28 articles for only 2 characters. This doesn't take into account that Castiel and Bobby also have individual relationship articles (although obviously not as many). Also, readers would not miss out on information because they only had 25 tabs open instead and missed a couple, or couldn't find all the relationship articles on one page. [[User:Trip391|Trip391]] ([[User talk:Trip391|talk]]) 10:18, July 4, 2015 (UTC)
 
This article should be deleted and merged with the relationships section of both characters, just like the other x and y character articles. Not because Sam only had six months with Mary before her death and Dean had years (both are still relationships), but because the information about all the different relationships the brothers had should just be included in each of the characters' respective articles. Essentially remove the listings of Sam and Mary, Dean and Mary, Dean and John, Sam and John, Sam and Dean, etc., and just consolidate it all into each characters' individual articles. By having multiple different articles for the relationships each character had with another character, readers are now forced to have to go to multiple different articles when they should really only need to read the one. Instead of having to read through [[Sam and Dean]], [[Sam and Castiel]], [[Sam and Crowley]], [[Sam and Bobby]], [[Sam and Jessica]], [[Sam and Ruby]], [[Sam and John]], [[Sam and Mary]], [[Sam and Ellen]], [[Sam and Jo]], [[Sam and Gordon]], [[Sam and Lucifer]], and [[Sam's Relationships]], or [[Sam and Dean|Dean and Sam]], [[Dean and Castiel]], [[Dean and Crowley]], [[Dean and Bobby]], [[Dean and John]], [[Dean and Jo]], [[Dean and Mary]], [[Dean and Benny]], [[Dean and Charlie]], [[Dean and Death]], [[Dean and Ellen]], [[Dean and Ruby]], [[Dean and Lisa]], and [[Dean's Relationships]], someone would only have to read the [http://supernatural.wikia.com/wiki/Sam_Winchester#Relationships relationships section of Sam's article], or the [http://supernatural.wikia.com/wiki/Dean_Winchester#Relationships relationship section of Dean's article]. That's 2 articles for 2 characters, instead of 28 articles for only 2 characters. This doesn't take into account that Castiel and Bobby also have individual relationship articles (although obviously not as many). Also, readers would not miss out on information because they only had 25 tabs open instead and missed a couple, or couldn't find all the relationship articles on one page. [[User:Trip391|Trip391]] ([[User talk:Trip391|talk]]) 10:18, July 4, 2015 (UTC)
  +
  +
I agree with Trip391. All the articles about relationships currently up just seem to document any interaction or mention of the other character -- no matter how slight -- from two characters with each other. We should just create a Relationship section for each character's page summarizing their relationship with other characters and any significant developments in those relationships. At the very least, there should be some major clean-up on the Relationships pages to make them more succint.--[[User:NaiflidG|NaiflidG]] ([[User talk:NaiflidG|talk]]) 07:13, July 6, 2015 (UTC)

Revision as of 07:13, 6 July 2015

This page should be deleted

This is NOT me hating on Sam at all, but seeing as they had absolutely no relationship with each other whatsoever, there's absolutely no reason for this page. -- ImperiexSeed, 3:47 AM, July 3rd 2015

How about deleted but moved to Sam's page in the relationship department. Despite only seeing her in the past for one episode, many of actions he does is from off his very limited time with his mother. As growning up, he didn't know a mother's love like Dean, but still was affected by her death. And every time he mentions her it's significant to his personality.[[User:Twilight Despair 5|]] ([[The God of Creation]]) (talk) 16:46, July 3, 2015 (UTC)

Yes, please delete it. Mary had NO relationship or bond with Sam at all, so there's no need for it. -- ImperiexSeed, 3:41 AM, July 4th 2015

This article should be deleted and merged with the relationships section of both characters, just like the other x and y character articles. Not because Sam only had six months with Mary before her death and Dean had years (both are still relationships), but because the information about all the different relationships the brothers had should just be included in each of the characters' respective articles. Essentially remove the listings of Sam and Mary, Dean and Mary, Dean and John, Sam and John, Sam and Dean, etc., and just consolidate it all into each characters' individual articles. By having multiple different articles for the relationships each character had with another character, readers are now forced to have to go to multiple different articles when they should really only need to read the one. Instead of having to read through Sam and Dean, Sam and Castiel, Sam and Crowley, Sam and Bobby, Sam and Jessica, Sam and Ruby, Sam and John, Sam and Mary, Sam and Ellen, Sam and Jo, Sam and Gordon, Sam and Lucifer, and Sam's Relationships, or Dean and Sam, Dean and Castiel, Dean and Crowley, Dean and Bobby, Dean and John, Dean and Jo, Dean and Mary, Dean and Benny, Dean and Charlie, Dean and Death, Dean and Ellen, Dean and Ruby, Dean and Lisa, and Dean's Relationships, someone would only have to read the relationships section of Sam's article, or the relationship section of Dean's article. That's 2 articles for 2 characters, instead of 28 articles for only 2 characters. This doesn't take into account that Castiel and Bobby also have individual relationship articles (although obviously not as many). Also, readers would not miss out on information because they only had 25 tabs open instead and missed a couple, or couldn't find all the relationship articles on one page. Trip391 (talk) 10:18, July 4, 2015 (UTC)

I agree with Trip391. All the articles about relationships currently up just seem to document any interaction or mention of the other character -- no matter how slight -- from two characters with each other. We should just create a Relationship section for each character's page summarizing their relationship with other characters and any significant developments in those relationships. At the very least, there should be some major clean-up on the Relationships pages to make them more succint.--NaiflidG (talk) 07:13, July 6, 2015 (UTC)