|“||He is so brave.||”|
— Sherri talking about Dean
Sherri was in the City Bank of Milwaukee when Ronald Reznick took everyone hostage.
However, a shapeshifter is inside the bank and tries to take on different forms to avoid detection. Its latest choice is Sherri. The shifter takes on the form of her dead body, to make the Winchesters go after the real one and accuse her of being the shifter.
However, the real Sherri faints during interrogation, and the brothers realize the corpse is the shifter. Dean eventually tracks it down and kills it.
Afterwards, Sherri and the other survivors are escorted from the building by the SWAT team.
Months later, public defender Mara Daniels contacts Sherri after Sam and Dean are arrested in Arkansas. Daniels reports to Special Agent Victor Henriksen that Sherri swears up and down that the Winchesters saved her life, but wouldn't be specific. Sherri's statement along with other inconsistencies in the case against the Winchesters causes Daniels to start to doubt the Winchesters' guilt.
- Actress Georgia Craig said in an interview that the Supernatural crew worked like "a well oiled machine".