Scotty is the owner of a cafe in Burkitsville, Indiana.
The first time he appears he is seen sitting on a bench, Dean Winchester approached him to ask whether he saw Vince Parker and Holly Parker, Scotty said he hadn't seen them and Dean went away. Scotty was in his cafe and was handling Steve and Pauly, when Dean entered and talked to them. Scotty then called the sheriff after this happened.
Later Scotty, Harley, Stacey and the Sheriff captured Dean Winchester and tried to sacrifice him along with Emily Jorgeson to their god. After Dean and Emily escaped, Harley and his wife were killed by the Vanir, and Scotty with the Sheriff fled.