|“|| Renny: I was at the top of my class at Kendricks--|
Eileen: No one cares.
— Renny's (failed) introduction
Renny Rawling (1992 - 2017) was a member of the British Men of Letters.
Renny is given the task by Doctor Hess to keep an eye on Mick Davies, who is on his last assignment to recruit the American hunters or else kill them. Mick is not entirely pleased with having Renny tag along, but Mick introduces Renny to the Winchesters nonetheless.
When Sam and Dean reveal they are trying to capture Lucifer's kid, Mick and Renny decide to join in. After luring the child's mother, Kelly Kline, into a trap, Dean Winchester brings here to the group's location. Both Mick and Renny want Kelly to abort the child for it is too dangerous, but Sam and Dean wish to handle the situation themselves.
Eileen Leahy, a friend of the Winchesters, tries to shoot Dagon using the Colt, but Dagon teleports out of the way, leading the bullet to hit Renny instead. Renny collapses and dies from the wound, and his death drives Mick to try and kill Eileen in retaliation, as per protocol. However, Sam manages to convince Mick to ignore the code and let them go.
Mick does, but Doctor Hess doesn't approve. She orders Arthur Ketch to shoot Mick for disobeying the rules. Eileen is also distraught for having killed someone accidentally.
In There's Something About Mary, after Eileen is killed by Arthur with a hellhound, the Winchesters receive a letter from Eileen stating that she was sure the British Men of Letters were after her for killing Renny and had discovered surveillance equipment, causing her to flee Ireland in fear for her life.
While attempting to kill the Prince of Hell Dagon, Eileen fired at her with the Colt. However, Dagon teleported away at the last moment and the Colt bullet hit Renny, who was standing behind Dagon, in the heart, accidentally killing him.
Renny was rather vain. When meeting both Dean Winchester and Eileen, he told them separately about his academic success in school, something both hunters ignored. Despite his apparently high intellect, Renny was clumsy enough to stand behind Dagon, causing Eileen's bullet to hit him.
- Doctor Hess revealed that he was one of the best British Men of Letters, and as such, she trusted him a lot, even assigning him to be her lackey.
- He graduated at the top of his class at Kendricks Academy.
- Mick Davies refers to Renny as Doctor Hess' lap dog.
- Any time Renny tells someone of his academic achievements, they tell him that they don't care.