|“||Welcome to Plucky's, where all your dreams are good.||”|
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie is a place where "kids' dreams come true", often hosting birthday parties. This store is a vibrant playhouse for kids.
Sam and Dean Winchester went to a local Plucky's when they learned of strange killings, ranging from a man "sucked" to death or impaled through a solid fence. After doing some more in-depth investigation, they were able to figure out that the manners of the deaths came from some of the children's drawings of their worst fears. It turned out that Plucky's employee Howard was traumatized as a kid by the drowning of his brother and after being passed over for manager of the store, he used his fear-based magic to punish neglectful or bad parents, operating out of the subbasement of the store. After Dean killed Howard by turning his own magic against him, Plucky's became a safe place once again.
According to Tyler, their pizza tastes like "butt", which Dean initially dissuades against, however he soon agrees, spitting it out. Through the name of the store, it's clown-based.
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie was staffed by: