|“||When I was little, I would come home from church and talk about the Devil. My parents would tell me to stop being so literal. I guess I showed them, huh?||”|
— Nancy to Dean
in Jus In Bello
Nancy, the secretary at the sheriff's office that was under siege by Lilith's demons, was a devout Catholic. She responded to Sam's request for a towel after Dean got shot, only to be grabbed by him as he stole her crucifix. She watched as the brothers exorcised the demon from Henriksen and was amazed by it. Later she helped patch Dean's wound.
Voluntarily celibate, she volunteered herself as the virgin sacrifice in Ruby's suggested plan to perform a spell and destroy the attacking demons. Dean, however, didn't approve and came up with an alternate plan that wouldn't require a sacrifice.
Nancy helped during the alternate plan, and survived the siege, only to be killed by Lilith along with the rest of people in the building shortly after Sam and Dean left.
Her death was later avenged after Sam killed Lilith.
- The actress who plays Nancy, Aimee Garcia, also plays Ella Lopez in the series Lucifer. Nancy and Ella have some characteristics in common, such as being religious, working with the police and meeting a supernatural being related to Lucifer.