Mr. Pogue was the father of Billy Pogue.
Mr. Pogue took his son to a friend's birthday party at Plucky's, but decided to take Billy home before cake and presents. When Billy asked to stay for five more minutes, Mr. Pogue threw a major tantrum and started screaming.
That night, Mr. Pogue was chased and killed by a unicorn. His wife was distraught. Dean Winchester investigated the death and realized Billy had a fear of unicorns. He later discovered that one of Plucky's employees, Howard, used magic to bring a child's fear to life and use whatever the child feared to kill the abusive parent.