This man was approached by Dean and Tessa while sitting outside eating a pizza. Dean could tell that the man was about to have a heart attack, which he did. After Dean reaped him, his ghost appeared and asked why did he die.
Dean hinted at the extra cheese, a cause of death the man accepted since he enjoyed the meal. When the man asked Dean what "it all means", Dean replied using a phrase from a Kansas song, much to the man's chagrin.
Tessa apologized on Dean's behalf, telling the man that Dean is new before talking the man away.
- This man dressed very similarly to Castiel, wearing a beige trench coat over a black suit with a blue tie.