|“||Right. Right. 'Cause you're not Ruby. You... I mean, how could you be? You... Of course! You are the lovely actress who plays Ruby. And you are, uh, in...Jared's house, uh, because you two are... Married! You married fake Ruby?||”|
When Sam and Dean arrive at Jared's mansion in an alternate reality, Genevieve approaches them and kisses Sam, who she believes to be her husband. She seems surprised that "Jensen" is in their home for what is apparently the first time. It is inferred that Jensen, in this reality, often calls her Ruby and refers to their pet Alpaca as a camel, much to Genevieve's annoyance. She mentions that "at least they're talking" before heading out to a charity function for the International Otter Adoption Fund.
After she returns from the charity dinner, Sam asks her about all the natural disasters that occurred in the last year, and she says that she remembers them from last season in the TV Show - apparently, the Apocalypse wasn't a threat in this reality. She tells him that he's been Sam Winchester for too long and then kisses him before pulling him upstairs with her, presumably for sex. Later, she tearfully tells Sam and Dean that Misha Collins has been stabbed to death. She is shocked when they ask where he was stabbed, as opposed to offering moral support.
- Like most of the characters seen on the episode The French Mistake, Genevieve Padalecki is based on the eponymous real-life actress playing Ruby in Season 4, as well as the wife of Jared Padalecki.