A week after Drew's death, Sam found a news report on his disappearance three years before. Sam realized that Drew was likely possessed by a demon and decided to look into his death in hopes of finding a clue towards Dean's location. Sam learned of Dean killing Drew, a friend of Cole Trenton sends Cole a picture from the security footage of Dean killing Drew, sparking Cole's own hunt for Dean.
After getting Dean's location from Crowley, the demon possessing Drew Neely attacked him at a gas station with an angel blade to get revenge for the death of Abaddon. However, Dean was now a Knight of Hell and easily overpowered the demon, ultimately killing him with the First Blade.
- On Drew's cellphone, his background picture is of the human Drew sitting on a motorcycle, presumably taken before his possession.
- According to the gas station clerk, Mickey, the demon possessing Drew left his cellphone behind the toilet paper in the gas station bathroom.