|“||Sam... (...) It was just supposed to be a little nest, maybe three vampires. Claire and I went in armed to the teeth, but there were more. So many more. She's dead, Sam. Claire's dead.||”|
After the Winchesters locked God away, Jody continued hunting with Claire and the rest of her family. However, while on a routine vampire hunt, Jody and Claire encountered a larger than expected nest, leading to Claire's death. A devastated Jody later delivered the news to Sam and Dean. As monsters began running rampant, Jody also lost Donna, Alex and Patience, leading her to become suicidal and one of the few friends of the Winchesters still hunting alongside Bobby Singer.
This timeline and version of Claire was erased from existence after Sam chose not to trap God based on what he saw.