Supernatural Wiki

Benny Sutton was a resident of Sioux Falls.


Benny resided in a trailer five miles away from Bobby Singer's house. He was regarded as a horrible person, and Bobby stated that there were people who wanted him dead.

Five years prior to his own death, Benny shot a man named Clay James Thompson in the back in a supposed "hunting accident". In 2010, Clay was brought back to life by the Horseman Death. Benny, who was watching a documentary about cheetahs, went to investigate a knock on his door and was horrified to see Clay, who proceeded to strangle him to death in revenge.

This incident was witnessed by Digger Wells, who passed on the information to Sam and Dean Winchester when they came to investigate.