Appointment In Samarra is the 11th episode and the mid-season finale of Season 6. It aired on December 10, 2010.
|There was something about being there... It felt pure.|
This episode summary is an official CW press release. It may contain errors.
DO NOT CHANGE!
Dean seeks out Death (guest star Julian Richings) to help get Sam's soul back. Death tells Dean he will help Sam if Dean will agree to act as Death for 24 hours. Meanwhile, Sam decides he doesn't want his soul back and asks Balthazar (guest star Sebastian Roché) for a protective spell to keep his soul out of his body. Balthazar tells Sam he needs the blood of his father for the spell to work and since John Winchester is dead, Sam decides Bobby (Jim Beaver) is the next best thing.
Dean goes to see an old acquaintance of his father, Dr. Robert. Dean pays the doctor and his assistant, Eva, to kill him and then bring him back to life. After the doctor claims a 75% success rate for the procedure, Dean gives him a letter addressed to Ben and asks him to mail it in case something goes wrong. Dr Robert takes the letter and then tells Dean he has 3 minutes of death before injecting him with something that kills him. Dean, once his soul has left his body, says a spell that summons the reaper Tessa. He tells Tessa to contact her boss, Death, and let him know that Dean wants to talk to him. She refuses, but, to their mutual surprise, Death appears behind them and greets Dean.
Dean tries to make a deal with Death to get Sam and Adam Milligan's souls out of Lucifer's Cage. Dean tells Death that he'll return his ring to him in exchange for their souls, but Death reminds Dean that he was only supposed to be borrowing his ring in the first place, and anyways, he knows where Dean hid it. He doesn't completely reject Dean's request, however; he tells Dean that he has to make a choice between Sam or Adam's soul. Dean hesitates but soon chooses Sam, and Death tells him that he can return Sam's soul to him, even putting Sam's time in hell behind a wall in his mind, but only if Dean wins their wager: Dean has to wear Death's ring and be Death for a day. If he takes the ring off, he loses the wager and Sam's soul stays in hell. Before Dean can learn why Death wants him to take his place for a day, Dr Robert revives him.
Dean tells Sam and Bobby about his wager with Death, but Sam is opposed to the idea. He doesn't want his soul returned to his body, especially because the "wall" Death proposes to put up in his mind isn't necessarily permanent. He tries to get to the ring before Dean, but fails, and Dean asks Bobby to watch Sam before leaving. After Dean puts on the ring, he appears somewhere else entirely and Tessa is there. She tells Dean that for the next 24 hours, he has to touch and kill everyone who's on her list so that she can reap them.
While Dean is with Tessa, Sam slips away from Bobby and summons Balthazar. He asks Balthazar for a way to keep his soul out of his body, and Balthazar, who wants to screw Dean over and have Sam in his debt, gives Sam the spell "for free." He also tells Sam that he has to make his body, aka Vessel, uninhabitable for his soul by committing patricide. Sam states his father is already dead as Balthazar states he "needs the blood of his father, but his father needn't be blood," so Sam resolves to kill Bobby. Bobby realizes what Sam is up to, however, and hits him over the head. Unfortunately, Sam vanishes before Bobby can tie him up. Bobby locks the door to the basement and then locks himself in the closet, where Sam quickly finds him. Sam breaks through the door with an ax, but Bobby has set a trap door outside the closet that drops Sam into the basement. Bobby asks Sam what he's doing through the basement door, but Sam doesn't explain. He escapes the basement and Bobby tries to track him, but Sam gets the jump on him and knocks Bobby unconscious.
Meanwhile, Dean and Tessa are busy killing and reaping souls. The first is an armed robber who is shot by a store clerk during a holdup, and the second is an overweight man who had a heart attack. Dean doesn't have a problem killing either man, but he is unable to kill the next person, a 12-year-old girl with a heart condition. He refuses to let her die, telling Tessa that there's no such thing as fate or destiny. Because he doesn't touch the girl, her heart miraculously heals so the surgeon and his nurse, Jolene, go home early. This changes the course of destiny, and Jolene is injured so badly in a car accident (which wouldn't have happened had she stayed to operate on the girl) on the way home that Dean is forced to kill her and Tessa reaps her soul "decades early." The nurse's husband, Scott, is then so distraught that he drinks and drives and almost crashes into a busload of people—the accident is averted at the last minute when Dean takes off Death's ring and jerks the wheel of Scott's car. Dean saved his and other's lives, but because he took off the ring he lost his wager with Death. Tessa tells him that it's over, but he still goes back to the hospital and kills the 12-year-old girl because he has learned his lesson: you can't mess with destiny or the "natural order" without setting off a chain reaction that has untold consequences.
Tessa takes him back to Bobby' house, where he is just in time to stop Sam from killing Bobby by knocking him out. They restrain him in Bobby's Panic Room, while Dean is distraught because he can't keep Sam locked up forever. Death then shows up at Bobby's house to get his ring back. He speaks to Dean about his failed tenure as Death, and is pleased that Dean learned his lesson about cheating death and disturbing the natural order. Even though Dean was unable to keep his ring on for a full 24 hours, Death decides to retrieve Sam's soul. He tells Dean that he needs to keep digging on the topic of souls before going to Hell and coming back with Sam's soul.
Dean and Bobby then see Death enters the panic room with a bag holding Sam's soul. Death tells a protesting Sam he will put up a wall in Sam's mind and advises not to pick at it, as Sam tells him to stay away. The episode ends with Sam screaming for help from a horrified Dean, as Death returns Sam's soul to his body.
Special Guest Stars
- Robert Englund as Dr. Robert
- Sebastian Roché as Balthazar
- Michelle Creber as Hilary
- Alison Araya as Jolene
- Christopher Kennedy as Hilary's father
- Bruce Dawson as Dr. Owens
- Primo Allon as Unnamed Robber
- Todd Thompson as Scott
- Aaron Tung as Store Owner's son
- Paul Bae as Store Owner
- Norman Misura as Heart Attack Victim
- Alison Wandzura as EMT
- Chaz Chamberlain as ER Doctor
- Stacey Bendfelt as ER Nurse
- Vincent Cheng as Chinese Butcher
- Danielle Benton as Eva
Featured Supernatural Beings
- Angel (Balthazar)
- Archangels (Michael and Lucifer, mentioned only)
- Ghosts (Unnamed Robber, Heart Attack Victim, Jolene, Hilary; Dean Winchester, briefly)
- Horseman (Death)
- Primordial Entity (God, mentioned only)
- Reaper (Tessa)
- Death last appeared in the Season 5 episode Two Minutes to Midnight.
- Adam is mentioned in this episode; he was last seen in Swan Song.
- Sam recovers his soul in this episode after spending 10 episodes soulless.
- Balthazar was last seen in The Third Man.
- Tessa was last seen in the Season 4 episode Death Takes A Holiday as part of Alastair's ritual to break 1 of the 66 Seals.
- Bobby last appeared in You Can't Handle The Truth.
- Robert Englund, an actor who is best known for portraying Freddy Krueger in the Nightmare on Elm Street movies, plays Dr. Robert in this episode.
- Sam's fate is revealed in Like A Virgin.
- Dean references the famous song "Dust in the Wind" by the band Kansas.
- Bobby's line "Don't say 'here's Johnny.'" is a reference to one of Dean's favorite movies, The Shining where Jack Nicholson's character says the line in a similar situation.
- The episode title is derived from an old Middle-Eastern story told famously by English playwright Somerset Maugham.
- This episode marks the last appearance of Soulless Sam until The Man Who Knew Too Much.
- The episode named after an ancient Mesopotamian tale: A merchant in Baghdad sends his servant to the marketplace for provisions. Soon afterwards, the servant comes home white and trembling and tells him that in the marketplace he was jostled by a woman, whom he recognized as Death, and she made a threatening gesture. Borrowing the merchant's horse, he flees at great speed to Samarra, a distance of about 75 miles (125 km), where he believes Death will not find him. The merchant then goes to the marketplace and finds Death, and asks why she made the threatening gesture. She replies, "That was not a threatening gesture, it was only a start of surprise. I was astonished to see him in Baghdad, for I had an appointment with him tonight in Samarra.".
- The CW's official summary for this episode does not cite Jim Beaver as a guest star.
- Bobby: Ain't nobody killing me in my house but me.
- Tessa: Wait, why are you dead?
- Dean: I need a favor.
- Tessa: Oh, you're kidding, you died to ask me a favor?
- Dean: Are you serious?
- Death: No, I'm being incredibly sarcastic.
- German: Der Tod wartet in Samarra (Death waits in Samarra)
- French: Rendez-vous Avec La Mort (Appointment With Death)
- Hungarian: Randevú a halállal (Dating wiht Death)