Okay, why does everyone on my poll click Bobby Singer? I say Sam Winchester should be my father :) I mean, who wouldn’t want Sam Winchester as their father? Not just that, but to have Dean Winchester as your UNCLE? Hell fucking yeah!
I'd want to f*** the Winchester boys and Cas is too much like a brother to them and I also think he's hot too. Jim Beavers is fairly good looking too, so the gene pool would still be there for me. And yes, Sam and Dean would kinda be like family, but they wouldn't be, which means.....