User blog comment:SeraphLucifer/Discussion/@comment-3481504-20151025043959/@comment-9249716-20151030040813

But then comes this particular question: if Death came into being alongside God (again, we can really take his word given his contradictions), how come when Dean told the Darkness about Death, the first thing it/she said "Who's Death?" Because if she knew God, and Death came alongside God, then she should've known who Death is. This is why I said we can't really trust he was telling truth but more likely trying to scare Sam and dean into sticking with the Natural Order, because given his contradictory statements and the Darkness confirming she didn't know who Death was, I think it's safe to say that whatever Death said about Anything before creation cannot really be trusted.