User blog comment:ImperiexSeed/Are fairies really capable of snekaing into Lucifer's Cage? If so, how?!/@comment-1509826-20120103193956

Well I do, after all why would he lie? He had sam at his advantage, he would have won the fight, if sam didn't have the sugar/salt, and he couldn't have known he did, or he would have taken it off him, like he did with Sam's silver knife.

He had no need to lie, as far as he knew he was just able to make a new deal, and get some more profit, and the lengends do say Faries can get in nearly anywhere, perhaphs like death (and possibly the other horsemen) they can or atleast the more powerful ones can.