User blog comment:ImperiexSeed/Death - NOT omniscient/@comment-1509826-20120606192358

Well I don't think it was ever said he was omniscient, just close, and he's atleast as old as life, I'm pretty sure when your that old your alowed to make a few mistakes, as for your points, for one, maybe as the first creations, the leviathans have sort of the prototype for souls, or maybe he ment older than human or monster souls, not souls themselves.

For part two, creation is a bit broad isn't? Creation of what, the leviathans? The earth? Heaven? Hell? Angels? Man? Beast? You get my point, there have been a lot of creations, so its possible that both statements can be true.

About the soul thing, yeah your righe about that, but he has to be close atleast, I mean only a few minutes later, he automatically knew everything about the problem in hand, and about castiel. On his first appearance, he knew dean was coming, and why, on his second he knew what dean was going to attempt, he knew where dean had hidden his ring, he knew dean was going to fail ect.

So sure he isn't all knowing, but you have to admit, he is damm close.