User blog comment:Rafe Adler/"Who We Are" and "All Along the Watchtower" Discussion/@comment-10889355-20170520135848/@comment-1975828-20170520163510

A good theory indeed, but then what happened to our Castiel?

AU!Bobby saved him, but then AU!Castiel appeared and jumped out of the portal and our Castiel did nothing? And what did AU!Bobby think of the portal? He was okay with two angels going in and out of his war-torn world?

My theory is that, if your theory is correct, then our Castiel was chased off, leaving AU!Castiel to examine the portal, go through it and find Kelly. But even my theory has a loophole, in that why did AU!Castiel never asked questions about who Sam and Dean were? He saw Lucifer and just charged at him, he saw Kelly and was very kind to her, both things you'd expect our Castiel to do.