User blog comment:A.J AL/Where does Death fit in?/@comment-26271908-20160529023830/@comment-26271908-20160529055154

Yes. I actually believe they were twins because We Happy Few was much about the balance between them, and I thought this implicated they were twins. But now I know she is older - Which I liked because I'm totally Amara's fanboy, just like I was Lilith's and Abaddon's

Now, I keep the theory that Death existed at the time to witness everything, but simply wasn't personificated yet. Just like God was light, Amara was dark smoke and the Archangels are beings made of light with several pairs of giant wings in ther backs. Like them, he didn't had a form. However, they had energy to represent them, and I would bet Death didn't had it until much later

About the plot holes - Yes, since after S5, that are many. Amara not knowing of Death despite his earlier claims about God can easily be explained without bigger issues. That are worser retcons, like Reapers being Angels or Lucifer being the first Archangel, who caused much discussion after a characther said a phrase using the wrong words to describe something. And, as of human nature, it would naturally cause a problem

I would like if, in Season 12, they solve everything and explain the lore. I know it's hard but it is not impossible. Just a few direct statements of someone who surely knows what they are speaking about - Not a human Dean or a 13.8 billion of years locked away Amara - And the problems would be solved

Jeremy Carver really sucked as a Showrunner. Season 11 was the one who most closely approached Season 5. With the potential it has, Season 12 can get in the level of it. However, I'm a little afraid because Supernatural excels in wasting potential. Just hope Andrew Dabb can make a great storyline like Kripke did