User blog comment:Twilight Despair 5/Fan Ideas for Fanmade Supernatural Episode/@comment-5619706-20140201145023

Great! This is awesome and has lots of potential. Here's my take and my input:

''And with this last Elohim not direc(t)l(y) part of God no more. It allows all the paradox of The Problem of Evil, free will and destiny/fate to exist now.''

This is brilliant! My question now is if the last Elohim is neutral chaotic, evil, or something else? If he was one of those two, then it would be fascinating if it was revealed that he whispered to Lucifer, influencing the archangel to betray his family. This is a two-fold plan: This allowed the Elohim to test how easily broken God's creations are, and to see how God would react if another being attempted to create a new race of beings. This way, the Elohim could assess how his strength would fare against God, and to see if he could start creating his own children and dimensions, or if he needed to wait until the time is ripe. By influencing Lucifer, the last Elohim created a scenario where there is a proxy or a substitute for himself that would attempt a new era of creation without the elohim itself from being endangered, and allowed the last Elohim to learn from the archangel's mistakes. Generally, this action also weakend the Heavenly Host, thereby reducing the existing powers that could rival or confront that of the last Elohim. We could also extend this to include Eve, for the reason that Eve also ruled a separate dimension and created beings of her own, and the last Elohim could even have created Oberon and the pagain deities. If so, then this Elohim arc would make all previous seasons connected and coherent, at the same time also effectively establishing the last Elohim as the one, true Big Bad of the series (it makes for a nice counterpart of Buffy's the First Evil, an eternal force that is sin itself).

Death, who is a stickler for the Natural Order, may have been so in lieu of God. Death keeps on trying to maintain the Natural Order to help God. And, despite Death's attempt to ensure the reapers are completely neutral, even some of his reapers have fallen to the last Elohim's whisperings. This would explain how some reapers went rogue. Death's few instances of breaking the Natural Order by directly intervening in life-and-death situations is for good reason: He allowed for Sam and Dean's constant resurrections, as well as the need to help Castiel to expel the Leviathans--because Death needed the three in his plan--to locate the last Elohim.

At this point, everything in the series would have been connected to each other, all major powers are involved, and the plot is central to the Winchesters and Castiel. (I'm really liking this!)

I'm not clear where this would be in the timeline of the show, but I'm disregarding most of season 9 because that is such a storytelling mess. So, if this is set somewhere post Season 7, but not around or after Season 9, this could work.

Now that almost everything is a mess, the last Elohim decides that the time is ripe for it to take action. By amassing its armies from Avalon (his army in Purgatory was basically too disorganized to still participate) and the remaining deities still actively within his influence, the last Elohim would strike at the very foundation of Heaven itself and actively attempt to destroy everything and re-create them in its own image instead.

Death may be stronger than the last Elohim, but for some reason the last Elohim has managed to evade the horseman, and Death is not keen in directly acting against the last Elohim since it would damage the natural order even more, so he assembles a team to counter the last Elohim's growing threat. Death enlists Sam, Dean, Castiel, Tessa, and Atropos (since the fates have everything to disagree with the plans of the last Elohim), with Death's most loyal reapers providing them support and back up when needed.

Now the only thing I'm unsure of is Hell's position in this. On one hand, it wants all the power for itself, but on the other, the last Elohim is threatening to destroy or take over hell as well. If hell is ruled by Crowley, then chances are hell would side with Death, but if it is ruled by Abaddon, it could most certainly fall victim to the last Elohim's whispers. Alternatively, hell could be split in two factions, one siding with Death and the other with the last Elohim. This would mean that the war would be fought in three fronts--heaven, earth and hell.

Now my question for you Twilight Despair 5, is whether the last Elohim is actively causing the nine aberrations to exist, or not. If he wa actively shaping the aberrations, then this would make it a more formidable foe. It could completely cut off earth from heaven by mere whim. It could cause all immortal beings to be mortal. Additionally, what about free will and evil themselves from existing? Aren't those already part of the nine aberrations?