User blog comment:Nightband/Season Seven Plot Hole?/@comment-71.236.88.157-20121213235809/@comment-71.236.88.157-20121214231426

Actually, Imperiex, that is exactly what Cas said. And the use of the word "would" is what led me to this conclusion. It is a conditional verb, meaning the predicate only applies in certain cases. I took it to mean "If he had an afterlife, where would Dick go upon death?"