User blog comment:Winchester7314/Possible Recuring S8 Purgatory Monsters/@comment-174.56.223.166-20120521160152/@comment-4920092-20120523192448

There's no evidence Eve is stronger than Dick. Additionally, Dick is invincible except for a weapon that could only be made on Earth (requires items from Earth (Fallen Angel Blood, Bone of a Righteous mortal), Hell (Blood of the King), and Purgatory (Blood of an Alpha) to make, so it can't be made in purgatory). Eve can be killed by phoenix ash, and (presumably) Phoenix go to purgatory when they die.