User blog comment:General MGD 109/Pheonix, Monster or not?/@comment-3481504-20120409004654/@comment-1509826-20120409194138

yes I surpose its possible it could, but do you get my point, the fact the Phoenix ashes being able to kill eve, could just be a side effect, a freak accident.

Also there is still my question, how would they know that Phoenix ashes could hurt eve, unless someone tested it, and if they did, then surely Eve would be dead.